top of page
  • Angel Gambino

Understanding the Different Types of Scorecards Used by VCs and Investors

During our recent Ready to Raise fundraising bootcamp, we discussed valuation methodologies that many investors use to evaluate early stage startups. When it comes to startup funding, one of the critical aspects that founders need to understand is how investors evaluate their company's current and anticipated value. Every investor has their own methodology and weighting, and three common valuation methods used are the Berkus Method, the Scorecard Valuation Method, and the Venture Capital Method. We took a deep dive into these methods during the bootcamp to help emerging fund managers and early stage founders gain a better understanding of these methodologies and we’ve summarized these in this post.

Understanding the Different Types of Scorecards Used by VCs and Investors

Venture capitalists (VCs) and investors are the financial backbones of the startup ecosystem, but navigating their world can be complex, especially when it comes to scorecards and valuation methods. For startup founders and entrepreneurs, understanding how investors value new ventures is paramount. This blog post will elaborate on the different types of scorecards VCs use and how storytelling can influence a startup's valuation.

The Berkus Method

One of the first simplified valuation methods a startup may encounter is the Berkus Method. Introduced by the renowned angel investor Dave Berkus, this method ascribes a monetary value to a startup based on several key attributes:

  • The Team's Experience: With enough expertise, a team can carry a startup through various hurdles.

  • The Product's Unique Solution: Innovation can carve out a valuable market niche.

  • The Market Size: A large addressable market presents a big opportunity for growth.

  • Potential Market Capture: The company's ability to actually seize a notable market share is crucial.

With Berkus Method, certain milestones can add $250k to $500k each to a startup's valuation, up to a maximum total usually not exceeding $5 million.

Scorecard Valuation Method

The Scorecard Valuation Method involves comparing a startup against similar companies in the industry. Here’s what often gets measured and weighted:

  • Founding Team Strength

  • Size and Accessibility of the Market

  • Competitive Edge

  • Product/Service Scalability

  • Growth Potential

Each element is assigned a weight, amplifying the importance of certain aspects like the team's ability over more quantitative measures such as revenue in a startup's early life.

The Venture Capital (VC) Method

For startups further along in their fundraising path, the VC Method provides a deeper analysis:

  • Financial Projections Analysis

  • Discounted Cash Flow (DCF)

  • Terminal Value Calculation

  • Risk Assessment

  • Market Comparisons

The VC Method encompasses a well-rounded approach that takes into account future financial projections, growth potential, risks, and market positioning to determine an appropriate investment and consequent valuation.

Example for illustrative purposes only

The Power of Storytelling in Valuation

Storytelling can significantly bolster a startup's valuation. Powerful narratives showcase the team's passion, vision, and problem-solution fit. However, it does more:

  • Connects Values: Sharing the startup's genesis story or issues the founder personally faced can connect emotionally with investors.

  • Highlights Competitive Edge: Narratives around the startup’s innovation can distinguish it from competitors.

  • Showcases Brand Potential: A strong story reels in users, creating an early buzz that investors find valuable.

Though indirectly, storytelling can enhance the perceived value of a startup, lending it intangible assets that numerical scorecards might miss.

Venture funding is a game of numbers and narratives. The Berkus Method, Scorecard Valuation, and VC Method each play a role in crafting the comprehensive picture of a startup's potential worth. Tactful storytelling acts as a leverage in this equation. Founders who grasp these valuation tools and harness them alongside engaging narratives stand a better chance of capturing investors' imagination—and their wallets.

For startup founders and entrepreneurs, this knowledge is not just valuable; it’s a necessity. Whether you are about to pitch for the first time or are deep in negotiation talks, understand these valuation methods, strike a captivating narrative, and watch your investment worth climb.

If you’d like to learn more about how Angel Club can help you better understand valuation methodologies and support your fundraising efforts, schedule a call with our Head of Community here! 


bottom of page